As I’ve mentioned many times before, my family practiced a kind of colorblindness when it came to me. I guess they figured if they didn’t “see” my color, no one else would. The problem is that other people did notice and on occasion, made it very clear. Try as I might, my blindfold didn’t fit quite as snuggly as that worn by my adoptive family.The ching-chong type taunting is just a given, not that I would dismiss these negative experiences as “just a part of growing up.” These were very painful experiences, but even more so, were very alienating. There was no one for me to turn to who understood on a first-person level. There was no “we” in my town. There was only “me.”
What choice did I have but to bury this “colored” part of myself as deeply as possible? Where did I have to run? The adults available to me had blinded themselves to my color. Racism didn’t apply to me. To them, I was not “the other.” Some part of myself didn’t trust that they would truly understand or be “on my side.” By choosing not to “see color,” my family had accomplished the exact opposite of what they’d hoped. They’d added another layer that separated me from them.
When I hear people hold up their “colorblindness” with defiance and pride, it’s difficult not to want to shout at them. This was a privilege that I was not allowed to have. I could ignore my reflection in the mirror, but not the kids who pointed at me and screamed “chink!” or told me to “go back to where I’d come from.” Even wrapping myself in “worldly love” wasn’t enough to keep racism from leaking in beneath the blindfold. I had no choice but to see, because the world out there wouldn’t let me forget.
I’ve come to view “colorblindness” in part, as another means of identity erasure. By choosing to ignore my “color,” my parents chose not to see “me.” Why was the yellow-brown me and all that came with it so horrible that no one wanted to acknowledge her existence? Why was she not worthy of acceptance? In essence, I became ashamed and tried to bury her. In a way, I began to feel not white, simply transparent.
Some of my TRA sisters and brothers have referred what I call “transparency” as “shapeshifting” or “adapting.” They become what their environment requires of them. As TRAs, I feel that many of us become highly intuitive experts at this. We can do it so well that we, ourselves don’t realize we are morphing until we reflect back on our memories. Sometimes we can become like Ged in Ursula Le Guin’s A Wizard of Earthsea and can be in danger of becoming trapped by the form we have taken. In a way, we lose ourselves.
As most of my readers know, I married a first generation Lebanese immigrant. I married young before I’d really gotten a sense of myself. Aside from being young and impressionable, I was still “transparent” and had little understanding of my own mind. Within the the span of a decade after my marriage, I had completely “shape-shifted” in not only form, but in mind as well. Still, there was the transparency. Identity-wise, I was not only mock-Lebanese Sume, I also became universally Muslim Sume. Both were facades I’d created for myself in order to “adapt” to my environment. “I” remained buried somewhere beneath.
This is a really touching post. I wish more adoptive parents could hear this. I feel so fortunate to be able to read your words. I can’t wait for part 2.
This is such an amazing post, beautifully written. We all struggle with shifting identity constructions, those imposed by us and upon us. Our identities can be both our armour and our achilles heels, as you’ve pointed out with the excellent example from Ursula LanGuin – “trapped by the form we have taken.”
I’m also reminded of the mythological fable of the seal who takes on the woman’s body to become human, as in “The Secret of Roan Inish” and so wonderfully written in Clarissa Eskola Pinkins “Women who Run with the Wolves.”
I love that you refer to feeling transparent, rather than white. This is a perfect way to express what we develop as a survival mechanism. I’ve found that many of us TRAs go through stages where we struggle to resign ourselves to colorblindness because that is what we are taught by those around us — that it’s “right” to look past color, “wrong” to focus on our skin. But, as you say, that’s a privilege that either we can never own, or one that we fool ourselves into believing we can master, if we deny our ethnic heritage enough. I choose not to buy into that illusion for all the reasons you express so well here. Fantastic post.
Thank you – that is a beautiful post, and appreciated by this prospective adoptive parent.
I had heard lip-service paid to colorblindness, but until my 20′s didn’t really think about what it meant. I’ll never forget when a close friend looked at my Asian American partner and very-white me and said “But you guys aren’t an inter-racial couple”. Followed by a brief moment of embarassed silence. It just had never occured to me that someone could really ignore the race of a friend. And therefore not acknowledge the racism that my partner (and now husband) faces on a daily basis.
As a PAP, adopting a child into our inter-racial family in a largely white neighborhood (roughly 10% Asian), I’m trying to figure out how to help support our daughter’s sense of identity, so that my family and our white friends see her as an Asian child. Thank you for the reminder of how important that will be. I look forward to Part 2.
Beautiful writing.
Thanks for helping me understand.
chiming in to say i love this post. i’m so sick of being transparerent and am working on not adapting to everyone else as a survival mechanism.
I loved this post and the photograph, It made me think of Harlow Monkey’s post about being married to a TRA.
This isn’t relevant to the post, (and you might know this already) but since I know you like to see Asian Americans in non-stereotypical roles, the lead singer of the metal band Trivium is called Matt Kiichi Heafy. You can read more about him here:
http://www.answers.com/topic/matt-heafy
Hope you don’t mind me adding that.
Hi Sume
I am currently putting together the ‘beginning’ of a lifebook for my child who is somewhere in China and whom I am yet to meet.
I feel great trepidation in how I will approach this incredible journey we as a family are about to undertake. My husband and I have dreamt about this little person for so long. We are reading all we can about TRA and trying to understand as much as we can.
Your post has helped me to think that I may be on the right track with the way I approach the lifebook. I plan on being very frank with my child. Saying that yes you are different to your father and I but no less loved. We don’t expect you to be like us in looks or actions. You are your own person and we are here to love and support who you choose to be.
I am constantly reading the posts of TRA’s so that I can learn to understand even an inkling of what my child may feel as an adopted person taken out of their culture and homeland.
To be honest you all kind of intimidate me. I sometimes feel that maybe I am too sensitive and you look on me as the ‘enemy’. I guess I don’t really believe this to be true. But sometimes it feels that way. However I continue to glean what I can from the TRA Blogs I read.
Thankyou to any TRA Bloggers reading this as I don’t know what I would do if you were not courageous enough to share your lives and thoughts with the world wide web.
Well said Sume. As usual, you offer APs things we can’t know from our own experience. Let’s hope that the world (USA in particular) is changing enough that “transparency” won’t even be able to exist. I for one say celebrate what you are.
Taking on things such as religion, culture, politics etc. is fine if it is your choice. Sure signs of individual freedom. Celebrate those things too and encourage others likewise.
great post sume…transparency is the the PERFECT word…how sad that we have to become transparent in order to just “be”.
I love your post here. The word I chose to describe these feelings when I was growing up was “invisible,” but I think “transparent” is much more accurate. People still saw me, because I existed, but they saw through me. Your writing is beautiful, and I hope to stop by your blog more often…
The word invisible comes to mind for me. I being a white adoptee in an environment that looked the same on the outside but felt fake on the inside. The real me was hidden, invisible. Nobody noticed it was all an act, not even me.
I can’t truly understand all of the extra layers TRA’s have to contend with but I can empathise on my own level and can grasp the concept of transparency perfectly.
Oh, and your photo is stunningly beautiful. A more perfect photo for this post you could not have found.
Thanks everyone for taking the time to comment. My apologies again for taking so long to reply.
Jae Ran thanks for the book mentions! They sound like something I’d love to read.
Ji-in, it’s interesting to delve into all the survival mechanisms that we’ve developed. Lately, I’ve been looking more closely many of them and how we apply them. Will make for some challenging blog posts, but it’s an area I can’t help but explore.
Safiya, don’t mind at all. Thanks. I remember hearing about Trivium before. *cough not that listen to that kind of music *grin But it must have slipped my mind that Matt was AA.
RogueQueen, it’s always encouraging to know that adoptive parents are reading and listening to us. This is a whole other blogpost that I’ve been working on, but it’s not that I see adoptive parents as enemies. My view is never so black and white or polarized as that. What I do insist upon though, is that I will speak as honestly and well..as bluntly as possible.
I can’t speak for everyone else. However, in a time when we are still being dismissed and/or pegged as anomalies, I think it’s important that we speak loudly and forcefully in order to get our point across. But that’s just me.
For me, it’s not about being against adoptive parents but about being an advocate for the many TRAs out there. Therein lies a difference.
vnbya, always nice to hear from you. Nah, it would be contradictory of me to knock taking on those things by individual choice minus the exoticism and fetishizing (not sure if that’s even a word). I think my case was a bit extreme though and not very healthy as I went from one kind of denial into another.
Hope all of you are doing well out there!
Mia, many thanks for once again chiming in and pointing out where our experiences are similar. When I read your blog, I’m often nodding my head and thinking, “Yes! Exactly!” I’m so glad you’re out there!
[...] The blindfold of “colorblind” Pt.1 – Ethnically Incorrect Daughter “As I’ve mentioned many times before, my family practiced a kind of colorblindness when it came to me. I guess they figured if they didn’t “see” my color, no one else would. The problem is that other people did notice and on occasion, made it very clear. Try as I might, my blindfold didn’t fit quite as snuggly as that worn by my adoptive family.” [...]
Although I found your comments interesting, being multi racial and adopted into a Caucasion family myself, I feel completely clear that your view, is not the only fair way to look at it. To be honest, I think you are pretty judgemental and lacking an open heart. Personally I don’t view my family as not completely well meaning in thier attempt to raise me “color-blind”; I think it shows maturity and depth and naivete, they thought of me as thier daughter, whatever my skin. Also they didn’t have the privilage that our generation, has, in terms of new studies and fields of interest re; ethnicity.
Its not all about race, its about intention and giving people credit. If some people adopt non white children and want to wait until the kids ask, to address it, that is not necessarily racist or wrong… just because you have a problem with it, doesn’t mean its a problem, I didnt…..I dont think this blog is beautiful, I think it is masquerading a lot of self-absorbed judgment and you don’t speak for anyone but yourself.
Well Llewis, you know what they say about opinions. As far as I remember, I have never claimed that my view is the only fair way to look at it. As many of my long-time readers can attest, I have always very flatly and clearly stated that I only represent myself AND that what I offer is perspective. I have also stated bluntly that I have no answers.
To be honest, I think you’re being pretty judgmental and lacking an open heart yourself, not to mention making a lot of assumptions based on one or a few blog posts. But I guess that just comes with the territory. As a friend of mine often says, “Hazards of the industry.”
[...] The blindfold of “colorblind” Pt.1 – Ethnically Incorrect Daughter“As I’ve mentioned many times before, my family practiced a kind ofcolorblindness when it came to me. I guess they figured if they didn’t“see” my color, no one else would. The problem is that other people didnotice and on occasion, made it very clear. Try as I might, myblindfold didn’t fit quite as snuggly as that worn by my adoptivefamily.” [...]